Located in the charming town of Honeoye Falls, New York, Main St. Cafe is more than just a local pit stop; it’s a culinary haven that artfully blends creativity with comfort. Situated at 58 N Main St, this cafe is designed to delight both locals and visitors alike, offering a welcoming atmosphere paired with a menu that reflects a unique twist on classic dishes.
As you step inside, you’ll be greeted not only by the warm smiles of the staff but also by the enticing aroma of freshly brewed coffee. In fact, the cafe has earned rave reviews for its exceptional coffee offerings, like the highly-praised Dark Knight, which one customer described as “tasty and full of flavor.” But coffee is just the beginning here; the culinary lineup is as diverse as it is delicious.
Main St. Cafe boasts an impressive array of meals that cater to various tastes. From their indulgent breakfast tacos to hearty wraps and sandwiches, there's something for everyone. The MSC Chicken Salad Sandwich and the zesty Tuckers Buffalo Chicken sandwich have become fan favorites, with accolades for their bold flavors and generous portions. Don’t overlook the invigorating smoothies either, particularly the BYO Smoothie, crafted to suit your personal cravings.
The avocado toast offerings are a standout highlight, marrying simplicity with sophistication. You can't go wrong with the classic Avocado Toast or the more adventurous Loaded Avocado Toast for a delightful brunch option. Each bite bursts with freshness, inviting diners to savor every morsel.
However, what truly sets Main St. Cafe apart is the inviting ambiance. With cozy indoor seating and a covered outdoor patio, it’s the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a meal at your leisure. Patrons have praised it as a cute brunch destination that perfectly balances a relaxed vibe with an upscale, creative menu.
In short, Main St. Cafe is more than a cafe; it's a community gem that offers a slice of culinary heaven. Whether you’re passing through Honeoye Falls or lucky enough to be a local, stopping by Main St. Cafe promises a delightful experience that will leave you both satisfied and eager to return.
We’d love to hear from you! Your email address will remain private. Required fields are marked *
Karl Miller
23/06/2025
Stopped to grab some coffee, noticed they had breakfast tacos. Decided to get a bacon breakfast taco. It was very delicious. The coffee “Dark Knight “ very tasty and full of flavor.
Robert Kaup
13/06/2025
Wow! What an amazing place. Passing through on the way back home from the Finger Lakes, and we stop for coffee. I was expecting a nice snack for the drive. What I wasn't expecting was a creative menu full of perfectly executed breakfast dishes full of bold but familiar flavors. The choices are diverse and fun. This place has all the pizzazz of a big city cafe without any of the pretentiousness. If you are passing through wonderful little town of Honeoye Falls please stop by this gem.
Cynthia Love
28/05/2025
This is the perfect small town coffee shop with an upscale creative menu. If you are close by it’s a must to stop in. I had a delicious speciality coffee frappe and a BLT sandwich with cheese and potato chips. Delicious!
Ilsa S
21/05/2025
Really great food here! My asian chicken salad was huge and had more chicken than a salad anywhere would have! The coffee is pretty good too. overall a cute brunch spot with covered outdoor seating so you don't roast in the sun.
CA R
29/04/2025
I absolutely loved this place! I got a breakfast quesadilla and smoothie. The quesadilla was the perfect size. Super tasty and flavorful. The smoothie was made with fresh fruit and was also excellent. I sat outside on their patio and it was such a relaxing and pleasant atmosphere. I can’t wait to come back!
Christopher Doe
22/04/2025
Very nice, cozy cafe. Food was amazing. Offer outdoor seating and have a good variety of pastries and sandwiches to choose from.
Kristen Ashman
16/04/2025
The food here is SO good, I always get the "Martin" sandwich. Quite a small interior, but they allow dogs inside (I personally love this, but if you have allergies or something be aware that it's pretty common to encounter a dog or two in the dining area)